How a Pet Food Brand Chased Its Tail with Big Ad Budgets

CASE STUDY: COMPANY BRAND IN PREMIUM PET FOOD SUBSCRIPTIONS

FOCUS: BURN RATE BRANDING | AUDIENCE: INVESTORS IN SLUGGISH BRANDS

I helped a premium pet food subscription brand realise that scaling doesn’t work when you’re running in circles.

The Brand Challenge

Despite raising a healthy round of seed funding, this direct-to-consumer pet food brand hit a wall it didn’t see coming. It had huge ad budgets, the influencer lineup, and the “organic + vet-certified” pitch down pat. But traction lagged behind targets. Month after month, the brand poured money into performance marketing—and ended up with more data than demand.

I was brought in by concerned investors, frustrated by the brand’s burn rate and confused CAC metrics. The real issue? The brand stood for nothing unique. Five other competitors were shouting the same ingredients, same tone, same wellness promise—leaving consumers with no reason to choose one over the other.

The Brand Insight

When I dug into customer feedback and interaction patterns, one pattern emerged: pet parents weren’t just buying food. They were seeking validation for how they cared. They wanted to feel like good guardians—not just subscribers. The emotional hunger wasn’t being fed. And that was the brand’s blind spot.

What the team had ignored was how emotionally nuanced the pet–parent relationship is. Pet care isn’t transactional—it’s tender. But the brand’s campaigns were all transactional. No wonder the campaigns had plenty of reach but zero resonance.

The Big Brand Idea

I reframed the brand’s offer from “convenient pet food delivery” to “The 3-Minute Bond”—a daily wellness ritual between pet and parent. Instead of pitching functional benefits, we built an idea where the meal moment itself became a symbol of love, trust, and joy.

Every meal was now not just a product, but a pause. A connection. This idea allowed the brand to create meaning beyond the bowl—and to own an emotional space no other brand had staked. It offered a content hook, a social story, and a reason to return.

The Brand New Strategy

I pivoted the company to a trust-led content ecosystem centred around this emotional reframe. The brand’s channels now celebrated moments, not features. Meal rituals. Little nudges of joy. Bite-sized wellness wins. The shift wasn’t in the product—but in how it was emotionally experienced.

Simultaneously, I worked with the investor group to restructure ad spend logic—prioritising engagement over empty impressions, and community creation over influencer churn. We even launched a customer wall-of-love, turning real users into brand heroes and story seeds.

10 New Content Directions

Here are 10 strategic ideas developed (and several executed) to support the new brand direction:

“3-Minute Bond” Video Series – Micro-films capturing meal-time rituals between pets and their humans, shared across Instagram Reels and YouTube Shorts.
Bond Builder Quiz – A quiz-led funnel on the homepage helping pet parents find their “ritual style,” followed by personalised content and product recommendations.
Pet Parent Diaries Blog – A first-person blog series written in the voices of diverse pet parents, creating relatability and repeat traffic.
User-Generated Bond Moments – A hashtag campaign (#My3MinuteBond) encouraging users to share their daily pet rituals, with monthly giveaways.
Pet Meal Ritual Cards – Downloadable, printable “ritual tip cards” emailed weekly to subscribers, blending advice and affirmations.
Digital Welcome Ritual Kit – New subscribers received a welcome email sequence with emotional bonding tips and curated story content.
Community Feature Wall – Real pet parent photos and mini-stories showcased on the homepage and email newsletters to build brand belonging.
Micro-Story Carousel Ads – Instead of loud banners, carousel ads quietly told 5-second bonding vignettes, driving higher engagement.
Weekly Pet Bonding Polls – Instagram Stories polls on pet routines, building interaction and surfacing audience insights.
Meal Moment Newsletter – A Sunday email filled with short stories, quotes, and user content built around the pet–parent connection.

Results Within 6 Months

CAC dropped by 38% as referral and organic engagement surged.
Average subscriber retention rose from 3.2 months to 6.5 months.
Branded search queries increased by 4.6X, indicating mindshare growth.
Investors approved a second round of growth funding with renewed confidence.

CONFIDENTIALITY CAVEAT: This case study represents a confidential engagement. For privacy, specific brand identifiers, campaign names, and project phases have been withheld. It has been shared with permission while preserving client discretion.

Extra Tip for Broader Perspective

If you’re brand owner or manager seeking stronger brand performance, here’s a case study that could interest you: “How a Children’s Furniture Brand Re-Assembled Its Untold Story.“

And if you’re a solo expert looking to sharpen traction, this case study I worked on may resonate: “How a Financial Advisor Got Off the Spreadsheet Into the Spotlight.“

Take your brand from stuck to full throttle − with one bold strategic shift

"One BIG IDEA can turn brand stagnation into unstoppable movement. Spots are limited each week—book your breakthrough session now."

Shobha Ponnappa

More Case Studies (and Breakthroughs) from the Burn Rate Branding Category

Subscribe For Strategy

I Bring You:

Smart insights, real-world frameworks, and idea-driven clarity – designed to help brands move.

Get my fortnightly Brand Reframe newsletter. Smart insights, distilled thinking, and focused momentum to help your brand lead.

Get my free case studies guide. Practical ideas, bold shifts, and clever transformations to propel your brand forward.

Just fill in the form to join. Get my newsletter and the guide shown alongside, all with several game-changing tips.

(No clutter. No spam, No fluff!
Your privacy is safe!)