FOCUS: BRAND STRATEGY MISFIRES | AUDIENCE: STEWARDS OF PLATEAUED BRANDS
BY: SHOBHA PONNAPPA | BRAND BREAKTHROUGH STRATEGIST | 45 YEARS | 125+ CLIENTS
I answer 6 tough questions about why some brand stories, though emotionally compelling, end up sounding unbelievable.
I often meet leaders who are convinced their brand story is unforgettable. They add drama, polish, and layers of triumph until it sparkles. Yet to the outside world, the story feels too good to be true. The disconnect is subtle, but once doubt creeps in, credibility begins to erode. In this post, I answer six common questions about what to do when brand stories misfire by aiming too high.
The simplest test is audience reaction. If people nod politely but fail to engage, your story may have crossed from inspiration to exaggeration. Stories that sound rehearsed, packed with superlatives, or disconnected from everyday experience often signal a credibility gap. Instead of trust, the audience feels distance.
I remind leaders that a story is not judged by how good it feels internally but by how real it sounds externally. Authenticity trumps theatrics. When your audience struggles to imagine your journey as true or relatable, you risk losing them altogether. Listening carefully to subtle cues … scepticism, silence, or polite disbelief … reveals if your story has tipped over the line.
Most plateaued brands feel pressure to reignite momentum. To do this, teams often resort to amplifying their past victories or inventing grand narratives. This attempt to look larger-than-life creates shiny but shallow storytelling. It comforts the boardroom but weakens consumer trust.
I have seen brands fall in love with their own hype. Internal applause blinds them. Yet markets reward grounded honesty, not inflated claims. When a story is decorated beyond recognition, even strong brands begin to feel unbelievable, leaving competitors to occupy the position of authenticity instead.
A believable story balances aspiration with realism. It carries ambition, but it is rooted in lived proof … real customer results, genuine founder experiences, and transparent brand values. Evidence-based storytelling turns lofty promises into credible narratives.
Believability comes from detail. The more concrete and relatable the examples, the more audiences lean in. I guide brands to anchor their story in real human outcomes. Without those anchors, a story, however inspiring, floats away into doubt.
Yes. A story that feels fake doesn’t just fail … it actively erodes trust. Once people suspect exaggeration, every part of the brand appears questionable. Trust is indivisible. If they don’t believe your story, they won’t believe your promises.
I have seen strong offers lose traction simply because their story felt inflated. This misfire damages sales conversations, investor pitches, and even employee morale. Great stories must also be credible stories. Otherwise, they create dissonance that slows growth.
First, strip it back to truth. Remove exaggerations, tone down the drama, and replace abstract claims with clear examples. Show, don’t oversell. If you say “we transformed the industry,” prove it with a concrete case. If you say “our culture is unique,” show what makes it so.
I help brands reframe unbelievable stories by anchoring them in proof points. Testimonials, data, and lived anecdotes bring balance. The aim is not to dull ambition but to ensure ambition is believable. A believable story inspires more because it feels achievable.
Create a discipline of story audits. Review your brand narrative every six months with external ears … partners, customers, advisors. If they raise eyebrows or question claims, recalibrate. This keeps your story fresh, credible, and relevant to evolving contexts.
I teach brands to keep storytelling tethered to results. Evolving proof keeps stories real. When a brand’s narrative grows alongside its actual impact, believability becomes a strength rather than a liability. Regular honesty checks stop stories from drifting into fantasy.
If these questions resonate, your story may be powerful but not trusted. That gap is dangerous because it breeds doubt even among loyal audiences. The fix is not to abandon ambition but to realign it with authentic proof. One strategic reset can turn a story from unbelievable theatre into compelling truth.
If you’re an investor seeking momentum for your portfolio brands, this FAQ Insight Post I wrote could interest you: “FAQs: When a Founder’s Network Limits the Brand’s Market.“
And if you’re a solo expert looking to sharpen traction, this FAQ Insight Post I worked on may resonate: “FAQs: When Prospects Keep Misinterpreting Your Brand’s Offer.“
"One BIG IDEA can turn brand stagnation into unstoppable movement. Spots are limited each week ... book your breakthrough session now."
More Breakthrough Ideas … Case Studies & FAQs … from the Brand Strategy Misfires Category
Case Studies
FAQ Insights
I Bring You:
Smart insights, real-world frameworks, and idea-driven clarity – designed to help brands move.
Get my fortnightly Brand Reframe newsletter. Smart insights, distilled thinking, and focused momentum to help your brand lead.
Get my free case studies guide. Practical ideas, bold shifts, and clever transformations to propel your brand forward.
Just fill in the form to join. Get my newsletter and the guide shown alongside, all with several game-changing tips.
Just fill in this form and get this awesome guide via email. Plus … each fortnight you’ll receive my Brand Reframe Newsletter that brings you smart insights, distilled thinking, and focused brand momentum.
